56 Comments
User's avatar
User's avatar
Comment deleted
Jul 31, 2023
Comment deleted
Expand full comment
Moe Murph's avatar

What a wonderful book reference. Thank you. Looked up this book and saw that none other than the legendary Alice Waters wrote its Preface. Cheers.

Expand full comment
Dena TB's avatar

One of my favorite books ever.

Expand full comment
John Lovie's avatar

InstantPot is your friend.

Expand full comment
G. M. “Matt” Lupo's avatar

I have better luck with beans in the pressure cooker. I dump in a pound of dried beans, about four cups of water and set it on the bean setting. They’re usually done to perfection in about fourteen minutes. I usually leave them pressurized for an hour or more just to be safe.

Expand full comment
Steve Lang's avatar

i think you’re supposed to soak them before you boil them.

Expand full comment
Jay R's avatar

Soak them overnight in the fridge. Also, simmer don’t boil.

Expand full comment
Donna M.'s avatar

Canned beans are not bad if you use the low salt kind and rinse them 🫘 🙂

Expand full comment
Patris's avatar

Lately I have failed miserably in my attempts. I’ve convinced myself these are a hybrid form unlike the ones I grew up soaking then simmering.

I stand by this like a soldier (kitchen version).

Expand full comment
John Wills Lloyd's avatar

Soaking before simmering is important, in my experience.

Expand full comment
Liza Donnelly's avatar

Haha! We are soldiers.

Expand full comment
Maggy Walton's avatar

Love the martini talk...bingo!

Expand full comment
Chuck Yanikoski's avatar

This won't be helpful, but I don't like beans and I know nothing about cooking them. So your cartoon by itself is not meaningful to me. But it could well be to other people with more adult tastes than I have. When you do a cartoon about Twinkies or Oreos, though, I'm all in.

Expand full comment
John Wills Lloyd's avatar

Presenting the topic in the setting of this drawing is excellent.

Once (or a few times) we had as a guest a post-grad scholar from the Yucatán Peninsula visiting us. He showed us how he prepared black beans at "home." He claimed that the key was cooking them for a long time (hours) over low heat and stirring (when he pronounced it, it sounded like "steering") them frequently. Mayhaps the people in the cartoon should his follow his guidance.

Expand full comment
Liza Donnelly's avatar

Thank you!

Expand full comment
Cheerio's avatar

You must try the brothy bean method by Alison Roman. She also is a big fan of a bean of the month club from Rancho Gordo that provides different dried beans to try as indicated. https://anewsletter.alisoneroman.com/p/brothy-beans-video ETA I have tried this method using some inexpensive pinto beans from Aldi and they were delicious.

Expand full comment
Edson Schaus's avatar

I was going to give a shout out about the beans from rancho Gordo too, but you beat me to it! So many different beans and recipes and some are just so darn pretty!

Expand full comment
Valerie's avatar

Bean of the Month Club is sold out!

Expand full comment
Cheerio's avatar

I saw! It isn't actually a monthly sub but a quarterly one and I hope you put your email on the wait list!

Expand full comment
Steven Brubaker's avatar

Some professional cookbook authors claim you don't need to quick soak, or soak overnight. Soaking reduces the cooking time, I don't think it adds to plumpiness. Old beans take longer to get tender, nothing to do with pumping up either. Whenever I cook beans, I pre soak either by boiling for two minutes, then putting the lid on w/ no heat for an hour, or soak over night. I've never combined both methods as you seem to have done. I think I've seen notes about not salting until the beans are tender. Of course none of this goes directly to non plump beans, which I've never heard of.

Expand full comment
Diana's avatar

May I be presumptuous enough to to suggest adding a word? “My black beans never get even mildly plump.” Just a thought...

Expand full comment
Candy Gourlay's avatar

Soak before you boil

Expand full comment
Helen Stein's avatar

I’ve cooked beans in most of the ways described below (except instant pot and pressure cooker), but never even considered that they should be plumped up! I love to soak them in beer. Despite my ignorance about to plump or not to plump, they end up tasting fine to me. My best advice to you: Don’t try so hard.

Expand full comment
billy foppiano's avatar

Liza, Always love your musings…

Yes, we get beans from this great organic guy who grows legacy crops…

He recommends putting a teaspoon of cider vinegar in the water to help remove the husk, which promotes better digestion.

Amazing, there is less um….gas generation. Yah know…flatulence. Altho, that can be the fun factor. Try THAT in an elevator.

Go gettem!

Yo fan, Billy

Expand full comment
Liza Donnelly's avatar

Thanks, Billy!!

Expand full comment